Will hybrid appraisals become the new normal? The FHFA requests input on GSE appraisal modernization efforts and how they could impact risk

Didier Malagies • December 29, 2020

Will hybrid appraisals become the new normal?

The FHFA requests input on GSE appraisal modernization efforts and how they could impact risk

The Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) announced Monday it is requesting input on the appraisal policies, practices and processes of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, especially as it relates to the GSEs’ appraisal modernization efforts.


The Request for Input (RFI) – open to comment until Feb. 26, 2021 – highlights specifically the benefits and pitfalls of hybrid appraisals, updating the Uniform Appraisal Dataset (UAD) and an increased use of appraisal waivers.


According to FHFA director Mark Calabria, modernizing the appraisal process has the potential to create a more “streamlined and accurate collateral valuation process.” However, if incorrectly adopted, Calabria said it could result in unintended consequences.


“Today’s RFI will improve FHFA’s understanding of how the Enterprises can improve the appraisal process while at the same time ensuring they don’t take on unintended or inappropriate levels of risk,” Calabria said. “The comments we receive will inform how we will modernize appraisals to improve both loan quality and the origination process.”


At the onset of the pandemic in March, the FHFA began easing standards on property appraisals that allowed drive-by and desktop valuations in certain circumstances.

Low mortgage rates fuel the demand for valuation and settlement services 

VRM Mortgage Services CEO shares how the company is navigating a difficult year, and how its services are impacted by the different national, state and local directives on foreclosure.


Presented by: VRM Mortgage Services

Now, the FHFA is considering implementing hybrid, or bifurcated, appraisals that enlist a third-party – typically an appraiser trainee, home inspector or real estate agent – to collect the data for a lender and certified appraiser once past the automated underwriting system.

According to the FHFA, hybrid appraisals would increase coverage for rural markets and high-volume areas where time becomes a greater issue. In August, several lenders voiced concern over the appraisal industry’s finite number of appraisers and underwriters as well as appraisal quotes taking anywhere from 10 to 27 days to hit the lender’s desk.


Though hybrid appraisals are expedited and typically cheaper, adding a layer of third-party involvement could complicate things because a uniform set of standards does not currently exist at both the state and federal levels that hold non-appraisers accountable for their appraisals, the FHFA said.


Alongside its easing of appraisal standards, the FHFA encouraged lenders to accept appraisal waivers when eligible. As a result, the Urban Institute reported a 14% increase overall in appraisal waivers, which contributed to an increase in refinance activity.


The FHFA suggests in its RFI that increased use of appraisal waivers could help lenders shave time off the loan manufacturing process, but waivers can also increase the risk of higher-than-expected prepayment speeds on mortgage securities, inaccuracies of input data and potential gaming by lenders.


The FHFA is also requesting comment on further updating the UAD, a process that began in 2018 in an effort to redesign its appraisal reports so they would be streamlined to other Enterprise data forms.

The redesign would also update the MISMO reference model that sets standards for the GSEs’ Uniform Loan Application Dataset (ULAD), and its Uniform Closing Dataset (UCD). Combined with the UAD redesign, the FHFA would establish blanketed standards for appraisals on all property types.


Racial disparities in appraisals were also on the table for the FHFA as it requested comment on the extent to which value determinations had potentially harmed minority borrowers.


A 2018 study by University of Pittsburgh professors found in appraiser interviews that some take racial and ethnic composition of the neighborhood into consideration when selecting comparable homes, though it is against Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice.



Bias in appraisal especially came to light in August after an interracial couple described their discriminatory experience in the New York Times. In October, a coalition of appraisal organizations announced a concerted effort to combat appraisal bias.



Start Your Loan with DDA today
Your local Mortgage Broker

Mortgage Broker Largo
See our Reviews

Looking for more details? Listen to our extended podcast! 

Check out our other helpful videos to learn more about credit and residential mortgages.

By Didier Malagies August 28, 2025
1. Getting Leads from AI AI can help you find and qualify homeowners who may be interested in a second mortgage (home equity loan or HELOC). Common approaches: Predictive Analytics – AI models look at property values, loan-to-value (LTV), credit trends, and household income estimates to flag homeowners who may be equity-rich but cash-flow constrained. Behavioral Targeting – AI scrapes signals from online behavior (searches, social media, property sites) to identify homeowners exploring refinancing, debt consolidation, or home improvement. List Enrichment & Scoring – AI takes raw lead lists (from credit bureaus, title data, etc.) and ranks prospects by likelihood of conversion. Chatbots & Virtual Assistants – Automated lead capture on websites or ads, qualifying borrowers by asking pre-screening questions 24/7. 2. Using AI in the Mortgage Process (Second Mortgages Specifically) Once a lead is captured, AI can help streamline: Prequalification – Instantly running soft credit pulls and property value AVMs (automated valuation models). Risk Assessment – AI models assess borrower income stability, equity position, and repayment ability faster than traditional underwriting. Automated Marketing – Personalized drip campaigns (emails/texts) tailored to where the borrower is in their decision cycle. Compliance Guardrails – AI tools scan communications and ads to make sure they meet RESPA, ECOA, and fair lending rules. ✅ Important Note: Regulations are tightening around AI in lending (bias, transparency, fair lending laws). Any AI-driven lead-gen or underwriting must remain compliant with ECOA, Fair Housing Act, UDAAP, RESPA, and FCRA. Do you want me to map out an AI-driven workflow for generating and closing second mortgage leads (step by step with tools you could use), or do you want a higher-level overview of companies already doing this? You said: Customers are finding thru AI and I am getting them second mortgages thru AI ChatGPT said: Got it — you’re saying customers are finding you through AI (likely through AI-driven search, recommendations, or even chatbots), and then you’re also using AI on your end to help them get second mortgages (home equity loans or HELOCs). Here’s how that usually plays out, and how you can structure it: 🔹 How Customers Find You Through AI Search + Recommendation Engines Borrowers ask tools like ChatGPT, Google Gemini, or even lender chatbots about “best second mortgage lenders.” AI-driven SEO tools route them toward your website or ads. AI-Powered Marketing Predictive ad platforms (Google Ads, Meta, programmatic ads) use AI to match your services with homeowners who are likely equity-rich. Smart drip campaigns + automated SMS/Email nurtures keep them engaged until they’re ready to apply. Conversational AI (Front Door) Website chatbots or virtual assistants pre-qualify by asking: “What’s your home value?”, “What’s your current balance?”, “What’s your income?”. These instantly filter serious borrowers from casual shoppers. 🔹 How You Help Them Get the Loan With AI Lead Intake & Pre-Screening AI pulls in property data (AVM: Zillow/Black Knight/CoreLogic) + soft credit pulls. Instantly calculates Loan-to-Value (LTV) and debt-to-income (DTI). Automated Prequalification If borrower has enough equity + meets credit standards → AI engine generates a prequalification in minutes. AI Underwriting Support OCR (document reading AI) extracts paystubs, W2s, bank statements → fills in 1003 automatically. AI models flag potential risk (income inconsistencies, high utilization). Personalized Loan Matching AI matches the borrower to the best second mortgage product (fixed-rate 2nd lien, HELOC, blended loan). Could even run “what-if” payment scenarios instantly for the customer. Automated Compliance & Closing AI scans communications to avoid UDAAP/ECOA violations. Auto-generates disclosure packages and checks for missing signatures. 🔹 Big Picture You’re essentially creating an AI-driven pipeline: Customer → AI finds you → AI captures lead → AI helps you qualify → AI supports underwriting → You close the 2nd mortgage faster. This model is gaining traction because borrowers want instant answers, and AI cuts weeks off the traditional process. tune in and learn https://www.ddamortgage.com/blog didier malagies nmls#212566 dda mortgage nmls#324329
By Didier Malagies August 25, 2025
Great question. Markets don’t usually wait until the Fed actually cuts rates to react — they move in advance, based on expectations. Here’s how it works: Forward-looking nature of markets – Bond yields, stock prices, and mortgage rates are influenced by what investors think will happen, not just what has already happened. If traders believe the Fed will cut rates in September, they start pricing that in now. Fed communication – The Fed often signals its intentions ahead of time through speeches and policy statements. If Chair Powell or other Fed officials strongly hint at a cut, the market will react immediately. Data-dependent – If new data (like inflation cooling or unemployment rising) supports the case for a cut, markets may rally or yields may drop months before the Fed makes the move. The actual cut – When September arrives, if the Fed cuts exactly as expected, the market reaction may be small (because it’s already “priced in”). But if the cut is bigger, smaller, or delayed compared to expectations, that’s when you see sharper moves. 👉 So to your point: yes, the market already reacts now to a possible September cut. By the time the Fed announces it, most of the impact could be baked in.  tune in and learn https://www.ddamortgage.com/blog didier malagies nmls#212566 dda mortgage nmls#324329
By Didier Malagies August 18, 2025
Here’s a clearer breakdown of what lies ahead for Social Security as it turns 90: 1. Trust Fund Depletion: A Real and Growing Threat 2025 Trustees Report projects that the OASI (Old-Age & Survivors Insurance) Trust Fund will be depleted by 2033 . At that time, beneficiaries would receive only about 77% of scheduled benefits. Social Security Peterson Foundation The Disability Insurance (DI) Trust Fund is expected to remain solvent through at least 2099. Social Security Peterson Foundation If OASI and DI were merged hypothetically, the combined OASDI reserves would be exhausted around 2034 , with roughly 81% of benefits payable at that time. Social Security AARP Other sources echo this timeline: some forecasts suggest insolvency might arrive as early as 2033 or 2034 , with 20–26% cuts unless reforms are enacted. The Week+1 TIME+1 The Sun Kiplinger investopedia.com 2. Contributing Factors to the Crisis Demographics : The worker-to-beneficiary ratio has plummeted—from 16.5 per retiree in 1950 to around 2.7 today—coping with an aging population and declining birth rates. The Sun investopedia.com Peterson Foundation Wikipedia Policy Changes : Recent laws like the Social Security Fairness Act (2025) that restored withheld benefits for certain groups raised payouts without funding offsets, accelerating depletion. AARP investopedia.com Reduced Agency Resources : The SSA saw significant staffing reductions—estimates suggest about 20% of field staff were let go —compromising service delivery. investopedia.com HousingWire 3. What Happens After Depletion? Benefits won't vanish—but if no corrective action is taken, they would be automatically reduced to the level sustainable by ongoing payroll tax revenue—approximately 77–81% of the current scheduled amounts. investopedia.com TIME AARP Peterson Foundation That represents a 19–23% cut in benefits. For instance, a retiree currently receiving $2,000/month would see payments drop to around $1,545–$1,600/month . investopedia.com TIME The Week 4. Solutions & Proposals to Preserve the Program Here are some of the leading ideas under consideration: a. Raising Revenue Payroll Tax Increase Tax hikes—from 12.4% toward 16% —could close funding gaps, though they carry economic trade-offs. The Sun The Week Wikipedia Bipartisan Policy Center Tax Higher Incomes or Remove the Earnings Cap Increasing or eliminating the taxable earnings ceiling, or taxing benefits/investment income, could improve funding. AARP Wikipedia Bipartisan Policy Center Kiplinger b. Reducing or Restructuring Benefits Reduce Benefits for New Recipients A modest 5% cut starting in 2025 could extend solvency only a few more years. AARP Means-Testing or Adjust COLA Lowering cost-of-living adjustments (COLA) or reducing benefits for wealthier retirees could help but are unpopular. AARP Raise Retirement Age Gradually Incremental increases to the full retirement age could yield sizable savings. AARP c. Structural Reforms & Investment Strategies Bipartisan Investment Fund (Cassidy–Kaine Plan) This proposal would inject $1.5 trillion into a separate fund that invests in stocks and bonds, aiming to generate growth over 75 years and preserve all benefits without resorting to general government borrowing. The Washington Post investopedia.com Brookings Blueprint Advocates a system that maintains core principles, ensures universal participation, and restores long-term solvency without expanding general fund use. Brookings 5. The Road Ahead: What’s Likely to Happen? Inaction isn’t an option—delaying reform would escalate the scale of necessary changes. Peterson Foundation The Week Kiplinger Politically, topics like benefit cuts, tax hikes, and raising the retirement age remain extremely sensitive. Successful reform will likely involve a mix of revenue increases, eligibility tweaks, and investment innovations , crafted in a way that spreads burden fairly and maintains public support. Some bipartisan pathways—like the Cassidy–Kaine plan—offer creative long-term strategies, but most require immediate bridging solutions (e.g., modest tax increases or cost adjustments) to prevent cuts in the next decade. Didier Malagies nmls212566 DDA Mortgage nmls324329 
Show More