"Suuper Seller" Housing Market Raises Fraud Risk to 13-Month HIgh
Didier Malagies • September 1, 2020
"Super Sellers" Housing Market Raises Fraud Risk to 13 - Month High
‘Super Sellers’ Housing Market Raises Fraud Risk to 13-Month High
National Mortgage News
Written by: Paul Centopani
The refinance boom kept mortgage loan application defect risk flat — at record-low levels in July — but fraud risk for purchases climbed again, according to First American Financial.
First American’s Loan Application Defect Index remained at 61 in July from June, but fell from 76 compared to the same period the year before.That overall annual drop of 19.7% can be attributed to the continual descent of the refinance index. The refi index decreased to a score of 50 in July, down from 52 in June and 69 in July 2019 — a 27.5% decline year-over-year and new record low.
However, the purchase component rose for the fourth month in a row, inching up to 83 from June’s 82 and 80 the year prior. It matched the highest reading since June 2019, driven by the intense competition of inventory shortages. In the last three months, the purchase index rose 7.8% while the refinance side dropped 5.7%.
“Historically low mortgage rates are prompting eager buyers into a housing market with a severe shortage of homes for sale, making for a very competitive home-buying market,” Odeta Kushi, First American’s deputy chief economist, said in a statement. “In today’s super seller’s market, borrowers have more motivation to misrepresent information on a loan application in order to qualify for the bigger mortgage necessary to win the bidding war for a home. If this dynamic persists, it is an environment ripe for rising purchase fraud risk.”
At the state level, Wyoming posted the highest defect score at 79, with 78 in Idaho and 77 in both Maine and South Dakota. Scores of 42 in New Hampshire, 46 in West Virginia and 49 in Alaska were the lowest. Meanwhile, Alaska exhibited the most short-term fraud risk growth, with its index increasing 8.9% in July from June. Vermont’s 7.1% and Pennsylvania’s 5.9% followed.
Broken down to metro areas, the top fraud risk index of 85 came in McAllen, Texas. Syracuse, N.Y., was second at 81 and Chattanooga, Tenn., third at 78. Scores of 47 in San Antonio and 48 in both Bakersfield, Calif., and Detroit occupied the other end of the spectrum.
The largest monthly jump came in Scranton, Pa., with index growth of 24.5%, followed by 7.7% in Des Moines, Iowa, and 7% in Allentown, Pa.
Since all loan transactions are now being done digitally, mortgage companies need to look for digital answers to combat and avoid any fraudulent applications.
“With a sharp increase in fully online transactions, lenders need to be more proactive than ever when it comes to fighting fraud,” Sam Bobley, CEO of Ocrolus, said in a statement to NMN. “The good news is that lenders can now significantly bolster their fraud defense capabilities with just a few lines of code. Lenders can deploy application programming interfaces to fight different types of borrower fraud and programmatically corroborate data across multiple sources.”
Start Your Loan
with DDA todayYour local Mortgage Broker
Mortgage Broker Largo See our Reviews
Looking for more details? Listen to our extended podcast!
Check out our other helpful videos to learn more about credit and residential mortgages.

Speed & Efficiency AI Underwriting: Processes applications in seconds to minutes. 1.Can instantly pull data from multiple sources (credit reports, bank statements, income verification, property valuations, etc.). Ideal for high-volume, standardized cases. Human Underwriter: Takes hours to days, depending on complexity. Manually reviews documents, contacts third parties, and applies professional judgment. Slower, especially for complex or edge cases. 2. Data Handling AI: Uses algorithms and machine learning to analyze massive datasets. Can detect patterns humans might miss (e.g., spending behavior, alternative data like utility payments, even digital footprints in some markets). Human: Relies on traditional documentation (pay stubs, tax returns, appraisals). Limited by human bandwidth—can’t process as much raw data at once. 3. Consistency & Bias AI: Decisions are consistent with its rules and training data. However, if the data it’s trained on is biased, the system can replicate or even amplify those biases. Human: Brings subjective judgment. Can weigh special circumstances that don’t fit a neat rule. Risk of inconsistency—two underwriters might interpret the same file differently. May have unconscious bias, but also flexibility to override rigid criteria. 4. Risk Assessment AI: Excels at quantifiable risks (credit scores, loan-to-value ratios, historical claim data). Weak at unstructured or nuanced factors (e.g., a borrower with an unusual income stream, or a claim with unclear circumstances). Human: Strong at contextual judgment—understanding unique borrower situations, exceptions, or “gray areas.” Can pick up on red flags that an algorithm might miss (e.g., forged documents, conflicting information). 5. Regulation & Accountability AI: Regulators are still catching up. Requires transparency in decision-making (explainable AI). Hard to appeal an AI decision if it can’t explain its reasoning clearly. Human: Provides a clear chain of accountability—borrower can request explanations or escalate. Easier for compliance teams to audit decision-making. 6. Cost & Scalability AI: Scales cheaply—one system can process thousands of applications simultaneously. Lower ongoing labor costs once implemented. Human: Labor-intensive, costs grow with volume. Better suited for complex, high-value, or unusual cases rather than mass processing. ✅ Bottom line: AI underwriting is best for speed, scale, and straightforward cases. Human underwriters are best for nuanced judgment, exceptions, and handling edge cases. Most modern institutions use a hybrid model: AI handles the bulk of simple files, while humans step in for complex or flagged cases. tune in and learn https://www.ddamortgage.com/blog didier malagies nmls#212566 dda mortgage nmls#324329

A new survey from Clever Real Estate shows that 61% of baby boomer homeowners say they “never” plan to sell their homes, a jump of 7 percentage points from 2024. The main reason? More than half want to age in place. That’s a big shift. Baby boomers now make up the largest share of U.S. homeowners, and if more than 6 in 10 say they’ll “never” sell, that has ripple effects: Inventory squeeze : With fewer boomers putting homes on the market, younger buyers have less supply to choose from, which can keep prices elevated. Aging in place trend : The desire to stay put often means investing in accessibility upgrades—things like stair lifts, walk-in showers, and smart home tech for safety. Generational divide : Millennials and Gen Z face higher borrowing costs and limited starter-home availability, while boomers are holding onto larger family homes longer. Long-term planning : Some experts note that many of these homes will eventually transfer through inheritance rather than sales, changing how housing stock re-enters the market. Didier Malagies nmls212566 DDA Mortgage nmls324329

Excited to share a major update that will make the homebuying process more secure and less stressful. President Donald Trump recently signed the Homebuyers Privacy Protection Act of 2025 into law. This bill is a significant victory for the real estate industry, as it directly addresses the problem of unwanted calls, texts, and emails that often flood clients upon mortgage application. What's Changing? For years, many borrowers have experienced a barrage of unsolicited contact from different lenders immediately after their mortgage application. This happens because of "trigger leads"—a process where credit reporting agencies sell information to other companies once a credit inquiry is made. Effective March 5, 2026, this new law will put a stop to this practice. It will severely limit who can receive client contact information, ensuring client privacy is protected. A credit reporting agency will only be able to share trigger lead information with a third party if: • Clients explicitly consent to the solicitations. • The third party has an existing business relationship. This change means a more efficient, respectful, and responsible homebuying journey. We are committed to a seamless process and will keep you informed of any further developments as the effective date approaches. In the meantime, you can use the information below to inform clients how to proactively protect themselves from unwanted solicitations. Opting Out: • OptOutPrescreen.com: You can opt out of trigger leads through the official opt-out service, OptOutPrescreen.com. • Do Not Call Registry: You can also register your phone number with the National Do Not Call Registry to reduce unsolicited calls. • DMA.choice.org: For mail solicitations, you can register with DMA.choice.org to reduce promotional mail. tune in and learn https://www.ddamortgage.com/blog didier malagies nmls#212566 dda mortgage nmls#324329